Okeela
Ideas & Belief

Is History Written by the Victors?

The phrase is repeated everywhere and proven nowhere. The reality of whose history survives is more complicated, and more important for Africa.

Illustration for “Is History Written by the Victors?”
Archives, griots and classrooms

Key takeaways

  • Losers also write history, and often shape memory more powerfully than winners.
  • European writers once denied Africa had a history, because they refused to count oral sources.
  • Oral tradition has strengths and limits, and works best when tested against other evidence.

“History is written by the victors” has the ring of a law of nature. It is attributed to Churchill, to Napoleon and to others, and none of them can be shown to have said it. As an observation it contains something true, and as a rule it is far too simple.

Where the saying fails

Defeated sides often write brilliantly. Thucydides, an exiled Athenian general, wrote the history of the Peloponnesian War, which Athens lost. After the American Civil War the defeated South produced the “Lost Cause” interpretation, which shaped national memory for a century. Memoirs of defeated generals, and the testimony of survivors, frequently change how events are understood. The real question is not who won, but who had the means, the literacy and the audience to be heard.

The African case

This is where the saying bites. In lectures given in the 1820s and 1830s, Hegel declared that Africa was no historical part of the world, and as late as 1963 the historian Hugh Trevor-Roper described African history as the unrewarding gyrations of barbarous tribes. The reason was simple: Europeans rated only written documents as evidence, and much of Africa’s past was preserved orally, in the work of griots and in the memory of elders. The colonial archive, meanwhile, recorded Africans mainly through the eyes of administrators.

The correction

From the 1950s, historians at institutions such as Ibadan, led by Kenneth Dike, began to treat oral traditions, archaeology and linguistics as serious evidence. Jan Vansina’s 1985 study showed how oral traditions can be tested and used. UNESCO’s eight-volume General History of Africa, completed in 1993, brought African scholars together to write the continent’s past on its own terms.

Editorial assessment

The answer is not to replace one story with another, but to ask of every account who wrote it, for whom and with what evidence. Oral traditions can preserve genuine memory, but they also shift over time and serve present interests, as written sources do. A fuller history comes from combining them and checking each against the others. Much has been lost or distorted, and recovering it is hard work, not a matter of choosing the sources we like.

Questions to think about

  • Whose history were you taught at school, and whose was missing?
  • How should historians weigh a song or a spoken tradition against a written document?

Disagree? Say why in the discussion below. Good arguments change minds.

Check what you learned

A short quiz on this article. Earn XP for correct answers.

Start the quiz

References and sources

  1. Jan Vansina, Oral Tradition as History (1985)
  2. UNESCO, General History of Africa, 8 volumes (1981–1993)

#Africa #historiography #oral tradition

Discussion (0)

Challenge the argument, not the person. Community guidelines

Join the conversation. Sign in or create a free account to respond.

No responses yet. Start the discussion.

Keep reading