Key takeaways
- The faith’s relationship with power changed dramatically after Constantine in the fourth century.
- Scripture was used both to defend slavery and to abolish it, showing how interpretation can follow interest.
- Tolerance and conviction are not opposites, but where to draw the line is a real and old disagreement.
It is the sharpest accusation a church can face: that it has made God in its own image. Every generation of Christians has made that charge against another, and often against itself. The history of the faith shows both how real the danger is and how hard it is to judge from the inside.
When the faith met power
For its first three centuries Christianity was a minority faith, periodically persecuted. After Constantine’s Edict of Milan in 313 it became favoured, and in 380 Theodosius made Nicene Christianity the religion of the empire. Almost at once the temptations changed: bishops gained wealth and influence, and the teachings of a crucified teacher were now defended by an imperial state. Later crusades and inquisitions, blessed by church authorities, are difficult to reconcile with the Sermon on the Mount.
Interpretation and interest
In the nineteenth century, slaveholders in the American South quoted scripture to defend slavery, and abolitionists quoted it to condemn it. The historian Mark Noll has shown how both sides appealed to the Bible, and how the literal arguments often favoured the defenders until a broader moral reading prevailed. The episode is a warning that people read texts through their circumstances, whatever their sincerity.
Tolerance and conviction
Modern Christians face a similar question about how far to adapt. Some argue that faith must speak to changing values, as many churches did when they accepted the ordination of women or remarriage after divorce. Others argue that the faith depends on fixed teaching, and that adaptation erodes it. Both sides can cite history: some changes that once seemed like compromise are now seen as recovery of older principles, while others are remembered as capitulation.
Editorial assessment
An outside observer cannot declare whose Christianity is authentic. But history offers a test: a version of the faith should be suspicious of itself when it conveniently supports wealth, status or prejudice, and when it softens the hard sayings while enforcing the easy ones. Jesus’s question, “Why do you call me Lord, Lord, and not do what I say?”, remains the most uncomfortable one a believer can ask.
Questions to think about
- Which teachings of Jesus are most easily ignored today, and why?
- Is changing a practice always compromise, or can it be faithfulness?
Disagree? Say why in the discussion below. Good arguments change minds.
References and sources
- Diarmaid MacCulloch, Christianity: The First Three Thousand Years (2009)
- Mark A. Noll, The Civil War as a Theological Crisis (2006)
#Christianity #church history #ethics
Discussion
Challenge the argument, not the person. Community guidelines