Key takeaways
- The New Testament assumes believers gather, as in Acts 2 and Hebrews 10.
- Hermits and monks show a long Christian tradition of solitude, often within communities.
- Reformers taught the “priesthood of all believers,” yet founded new churches.
More people than ever describe themselves as believers who do not attend church. They say they pray, read the Bible and try to follow Jesus, but find congregations disappointing. Is that Christianity, or a private substitute for it? The answer depends on whom you ask, and church history gives plenty of answers.
The case for gathering
The New Testament portrays believers meeting together: Acts describes the first Christians devoting themselves to teaching, fellowship, breaking bread and prayer, and the letter to the Hebrews warns against abandoning the habit of meeting. In the third century Cyprian of Carthage wrote that one cannot have God as Father without having the church as mother. For most of Christian history, faith was assumed to be communal, with sacraments, discipline and mutual care.
The tradition of solitude
Yet Christianity also honours the lonely seeker. In the third and fourth centuries, the Desert Fathers withdrew to Egyptian wilderness to pray. Even so, many were soon surrounded by students and organised into monasteries, which suggests that solitude often returned to community. Medieval anchorites lived enclosed in cells attached to churches, still part of a parish.
The Reformation’s tension
Martin Luther’s teaching on the “priesthood of all believers” in 1520 argued that every Christian has direct access to God without a priestly caste. Radical reformers pushed further, and the Quakers built a tradition that distrusted formal ministry. Yet nearly all of these movements formed new congregations, because people who believe the same things tend to gather.
Editorial assessment
History suggests that faith alone can be sincere, but that very few traditions have regarded it as complete. Most Christians through the centuries would have found the question strange. At the same time, the abuses and failures of institutions are real, and many people leave churches for reasons that deserve respect, not scorn. The fairest conclusion may be that a person can follow Christ outside a congregation, but that Christianity has always been designed to be lived with others.
Questions to think about
- What does a gathered community provide that private faith cannot?
- When does a church help faith, and when does it obstruct it?
Disagree? Say why in the discussion below. Good arguments change minds.
References and sources
- Diarmaid MacCulloch, Christianity: The First Three Thousand Years (2009)
- Cyprian of Carthage, On the Unity of the Church (c. 251)
#Christianity #church history #faith
Discussion
Challenge the argument, not the person. Community guidelines