Okeela
Sport & Society

Is Football Still About Talent, or Has Money Taken Over?

Every title race now seems to follow the wage bill. The history of football’s money shows how we got here, and why Leicester’s 2016 title still stuns us.

Illustration for “Is Football Still About Talent, or Has Money Taken Over?”
England, 1961 to today

Key takeaways

  • Wage spending predicts league position better than almost anything else, over the long run.
  • The sharpest breaks came in 1961 (maximum wage abolished), 1992 (Premier League) and 1995 (Bosman ruling).
  • Rare upsets such as Leicester City in 2016 prove talent still matters, and also how unusual they are.

Every August the same argument returns: the richest clubs will win, and everyone else is playing for fourth place. It is a fair worry, but it is not new. Football has been a story of talent bumping against money for more than sixty years, and the pattern tells us something the transfer headlines hide.

The cap that fell

Until 1961, English footballers were bound by a maximum wage, so a star earned little more than a skilled factory worker. Once the union forced its abolition, the richest clubs could pay what they liked, and the best players moved toward them. In 1992 the top division broke away to form the Premier League and sold its television rights, and in 1995 the Bosman ruling let out-of-contract players move freely across Europe. Each change moved more of the sport’s income toward the few clubs with the biggest crowds.

What the numbers show

Economists who studied decades of English results found a strong link between a club’s wage bill and its league position. Wages explain most of the long-run differences between clubs, which is not surprising: they buy the best players. The newer ingredient is ownership. Since the takeovers of Manchester City in 2008 and Paris Saint-Germain in 2011 by wealthy Gulf backers, a few clubs have been funded on a scale that no local business could match, and rules such as Financial Fair Play, introduced in 2011, have struggled to keep up.

The exceptions that count

Yet Leicester City won the Premier League in 2015–16 after being priced at about 5,000 to 1. It was not magic. They found undervalued players, played with exceptional organisation, and enjoyed an unusually healthy season. But the very fact that it feels like a miracle shows how seldom it happens.

Editorial assessment

Talent still decides matches, but money decides who gets the talent. The honest answer to the headline is that football has always been both, and that the balance has shifted sharply. If the sport cares about being a contest and not only a product, it needs rules that share income more evenly, as American leagues do with salary caps and drafts. Whether fans, owners and broadcasters want that is another question.

Questions to think about

  • If money buys success, is the game still a contest?
  • What would a genuinely fair football league look like?

Disagree? Say why in the discussion below. Good arguments change minds.

Check what you learned

A short quiz on this article. Earn XP for correct answers.

Start the quiz

References and sources

  1. Stefan Szymanski and Tim Kuypers, Winners and Losers: The Business Strategy of Football (1999)
  2. Simon Kuper and Stefan Szymanski, Soccernomics (2009)

#football #money #Premier League

Discussion (0)

Challenge the argument, not the person. Community guidelines

Join the conversation. Sign in or create a free account to respond.

No responses yet. Start the discussion.

Keep reading