Okeela
Sport & Society

Has Sports Betting Damaged the Integrity of Sport?

Betting and sport have been entangled since the 1919 Black Sox scandal. The difference today is scale, speed and a phone in every pocket.

Illustration for “Has Sports Betting Damaged the Integrity of Sport?”
Sport and gambling, 1919 to today

Key takeaways

  • Match-fixing scandals, from baseball in 1919 to cricket in 2000, were driven by betting markets.
  • Smartphones and in-play betting have made gambling constant and personal.
  • Regulators are only beginning to restrict sponsorship and advertising.

Gambling on sport is as old as sport. What is new is that it now sits in your pocket, offers a wager on every throw-in, and advertises itself on the shirts of the teams you love. The question is whether this is entertainment with side effects, or a threat to the thing we are betting on.

An old problem

In 1919 eight players of the Chicago White Sox were accused of throwing the World Series for money from gamblers. They were banned for life, though acquitted in court. In 2000, the South African cricket captain Hansie Cronje admitted taking money from bookmakers, and investigations soon found corruption in other teams. Italian football was shaken by betting-related scandals in 2011 and again later. Wherever money can be made from a result, someone will try to influence it.

What changed

In 2018 the US Supreme Court struck down the federal law that had restricted legal sports betting to a few states, and the market exploded. In Europe and Africa, mobile apps made wagering instant, with small stakes and constant temptation, and in-play betting allows bets on tiny events within a match, which are easier to manipulate. In England, Premier League clubs agreed in 2023 to end betting sponsors on the front of matchday shirts, a sign that even the sport’s richest institutions saw the problem.

Two honest positions

Defenders argue that most people bet responsibly, that regulation is better than prohibition, and that legal betting makes manipulation easier to detect. Critics point to evidence of addiction, especially among young men, aggressive advertising and the way clubs and broadcasters now depend on betting revenue.

Editorial assessment

History suggests betting never ruins sport on its own; corruption does, and betting gives corruption its motive. The case for tighter limits on advertising, sponsorship and in-play markets is strong, particularly where young people are the target. The case for blaming individuals alone is weak. A product designed to be hard to put down cannot place all the responsibility on the person using it.

Questions to think about

  • Who is responsible when a young person is harmed: the bettor, the company or the sport?
  • Should clubs be allowed to take money from betting firms at all?

Disagree? Say why in the discussion below. Good arguments change minds.

Check what you learned

A short quiz on this article. Earn XP for correct answers.

Start the quiz

References and sources

  1. Declan Hill, The Fix: Soccer and Organized Crime (2008)
  2. Eliot Asinof, Eight Men Out (1963)

#sport #betting #regulation

Discussion (0)

Challenge the argument, not the person. Community guidelines

Join the conversation. Sign in or create a free account to respond.

No responses yet. Start the discussion.

Keep reading