Okeela
Africa & the World

Would Africa Be More Developed If Its Kingdoms Had Not Been Disrupted?

It is a tempting counterfactual. The evidence suggests that precolonial states mattered, but also that nostalgia needs discipline.

Illustration for “Would Africa Be More Developed If Its Kingdoms Had Not Been Disrupted?”
Oyo, Benin and Ghana, before 1900

Key takeaways

  • Studies find that ethnic groups with centralised precolonial states tend to have better public goods today.
  • Oyo’s decline began before colonial conquest, driven by internal conflict and the wars of the early nineteenth century.
  • The slave trades damaged African societies long before formal colonial rule.

Imagine Africa if the Oyo Empire, the Kingdom of Benin and the Asante Confederacy had been allowed to evolve on their own. It is a favourite question of those who feel that the continent’s institutions were broken from outside. It is a worthwhile one, provided we answer it with evidence and not with longing.

What these states were

Oyo, founded in the fourteenth century or earlier, grew into a large Yoruba state with a king, the Alaafin, balanced by a council of senior chiefs, the Oyomesi, who could force an unpopular ruler to step down. Benin had an Oba, a hierarchy of titled chiefs and highly organised craft guilds. The ancient Ghana Empire, which lay in what is now Mauritania and Mali, controlled the trans-Saharan gold and salt trade. These were sophisticated systems, with courts, taxation, armies and law.

What the research says

Economists have tested whether history matters. Studies of Africa by Stelios Michalopoulos and Elias Papaioannou found that ethnic groups with more centralised precolonial institutions tend to show greater regional development today. Nathan Nunn found that areas hardest hit by the slave trades remain poorer. Together they suggest that both old institutions and old damage still shape the present.

Why the counterfactual is hard

These kingdoms were not static and not always stable. Oyo’s power weakened in the early nineteenth century through internal revolt and the pressure of the Sokoto jihad, decades before British conquest. Precolonial states fought wars, took captives and, in many cases, participated in the slave trade. Nobody can say what they would have become. They were also very different from one another, and none corresponds neatly to a modern nation-state.

Editorial assessment

Colonialism did disrupt existing political orders, by drawing borders that cut across them and by replacing local authority with foreign rule. It is reasonable to say that something valuable was lost. It is not reasonable to claim that the old kingdoms would have produced a modern prosperous Africa if left alone. The more useful lesson is practical: governments that build on local legitimacy, such as respected chiefs and traditional councils, often work better than those that ignore it.

Questions to think about

  • What can modern governments genuinely learn from precolonial institutions?
  • Is it fair to idealise states that also held slaves and waged wars?

Disagree? Say why in the discussion below. Good arguments change minds.

Check what you learned

A short quiz on this article. Earn XP for correct answers.

Start the quiz

References and sources

  1. Stelios Michalopoulos and Elias Papaioannou, “Pre-Colonial Ethnic Institutions and Contemporary African Development,” Econometrica (2013)
  2. Nathan Nunn, “The Long-Term Effects of Africa’s Slave Trades,” Quarterly Journal of Economics (2008)

#Benin #kingdoms #Oyo

Discussion (0)

Challenge the argument, not the person. Community guidelines

Join the conversation. Sign in or create a free account to respond.

No responses yet. Start the discussion.

Keep reading