Okeela
War & Conflict

Why Did the Zulu Win at Isandlwana, and Still Lose the War?

It was among the worst defeats the British Army suffered in the colonial era. Within six months the Zulu kingdom was broken.

Illustration for “Why Did the Zulu Win at Isandlwana, and Still Lose the War?”
KwaZulu-Natal, 22 January 1879

Key takeaways

  • A Zulu army overran a British camp at Isandlwana, killing well over a thousand men.
  • Victory did not change the balance of resources, and the British sent reinforcements.
  • The kingdom was then divided and weakened by British settlement of the aftermath.

On the morning of 22 January 1879, a British column in southern Africa was destroyed by a Zulu army. It was one of the worst defeats suffered by the British Army against a non-European force in the entire century. By the end of the year the Zulu kingdom no longer existed as an independent power. Both facts need explaining.

The war nobody asked for

The conflict did not arise from a Zulu attack. It began with a British ultimatum in December 1878, pressed by Sir Bartle Frere, the High Commissioner, who wanted to remove an independent military state standing in the way of a planned confederation of South African territories. The demands, including disbanding the Zulu army, were impossible for King Cetshwayo to accept.

The disaster

At Isandlwana, a camp of roughly 1,700 British and colonial troops was divided and poorly entrenched while the commander, Lord Chelmsford, led part of the force away. A Zulu army of many thousands, deployed with discipline and speed, attacked the camp and overran it. Over a thousand soldiers died, including many African auxiliaries. The same day a much smaller Zulu force attacked the mission station at Rorke’s Drift and was held off, an episode that became the centrepiece of British memory and earned eleven Victoria Crosses.

A victory that could not hold

The Zulu kingdom had won a battle against an empire with vastly greater resources. Britain sent reinforcements, and in July 1879 defeated the Zulu at Ulundi. Cetshwayo was captured, and the kingdom was divided into thirteen chiefdoms, a settlement designed to prevent it from ever uniting again. The Zulu political order never recovered its independence.

Editorial assessment

Isandlwana is a reminder that military brilliance and political survival are different things. The Zulu army fought with skill and courage, and the British made serious errors. But wars are decided by resources, endurance and allies, and the empire could replace its losses. The more telling point is how the British remembered it: they made a defeat into a heroic myth through Rorke’s Drift, while the political purpose of the war, destroying a rival state, was largely forgotten.

Questions to think about

  • Is a battle won in a war that cannot be won a victory?
  • Why does Rorke’s Drift dominate popular memory more than Isandlwana?

Disagree? Say why in the discussion below. Good arguments change minds.

Check what you learned

A short quiz on this article. Earn XP for correct answers.

Start the quiz

References and sources

  1. Ian Knight, Zulu Rising: The Epic Story of iSandlwana and Rorke’s Drift (2010)
  2. John Laband, The Zulu Wars (2009)

#Zulu #Empire #military history

Discussion (0)

Challenge the argument, not the person. Community guidelines

Join the conversation. Sign in or create a free account to respond.

No responses yet. Start the discussion.

Keep reading