Key takeaways
- Athens chose many officials by lot and examined them afterwards; imperial China chose officials by exam.
- Education is not the same as wisdom, and some highly educated governments have been disastrous.
- Competence and popularity can be balanced through institutions, not by banning one of them.
It sounds obvious: put the most capable people in charge. But the question of how to find them has divided political thinkers for twenty-five centuries, and no society has found a perfect method. The history of the attempts is more useful than a slogan.
Three old answers
Plato argued that rulers should be philosophers trained from youth, a proposal that appealed to people who imagined themselves as philosophers. Athens went the other way. Many offices were filled by lot, on the principle that ordinary citizens could rule, and officials were examined before taking office and held accountable afterwards. Imperial China developed exams, from the Sui and Tang dynasties onward, to select civil servants on learning and writing. Each system produced able officials and large failures.
The trouble with credentials
A degree measures something, but not everything. Abraham Lincoln had little formal schooling, while some of the most destructive regimes of the twentieth century were run by highly educated elites. Nigeria’s constitution requires a presidential candidate to hold a school certificate or its equivalent, a modest bar, and debates over certificates have shown how easily credentials become political weapons. Studies of modern leaders suggest that education can help national growth, but the effect is modest and depends on the country.
The trouble with popularity
Elections reward people who can win votes, which is a real skill but not the same as governing. Voters can also be influenced by money, fear and charisma. Yet a ruler chosen without any public consent often loses accountability altogether.
Editorial assessment
The strongest systems combine the two. They let the public choose and surround the choice with institutions that test competence: independent courts, professional civil services, audits and checks on power. The mistake is to believe that either popularity or credentials alone solves the problem. A mandate from the people and the ability to deliver are separate tasks, and a healthy system needs both.
Questions to think about
- Should a president be required to hold a degree?
- Who gets to define competence, and how would we test it?
Disagree? Say why in the discussion below. Good arguments change minds.
References and sources
- Aristotle, Politics, Book 3
- Tim Besley, José G. Montalvo and Marta Reynal-Querol, “Do Educated Leaders Matter?” The Economic Journal (2011)
#democracy #leadership #history of government
Discussion
Challenge the argument, not the person. Community guidelines